LOS GATOS — Police on Friday released body-camera footage and the results of an investigation into a former officer’s use of force in April, when, responding to a call about a disturbance he ended up bodily restraining a man and in the process fracturing several of his ribs.
The investigation, by police and two commissioned experts, concluded that Johnathon Silva used “objectively reasonable” force in subduing the man, identified as 57-year-old James Russell Newlon, who ultimately was issued a criminal citation but was not taken into custody. But the finding is essentially moot, because Silva resigned from the Los Gatos-Monte Sereno Police Department last month, amid controversy over the violence involved in an arrest he made in 2016, when he was working for the San Jose State University Police Department.
WARNING: This video contains graphic content. Viewer discretion is advised. CLICK HERE if you have trouble viewing the video on a mobile device.
A public statement and YouTube video of body-camera footage from the April 19, 2019 encounter, in the 100 block of Towne Terrace, was posted by the police department Friday in response to Senate Bill 1421, the new police transparency law.
The law compelled the release of previously protected disciplinary records when an officer was found to have engaged in sexual assault or dishonesty, or was involved in an officer-involved shooting or use of force that caused great bodily injury.
According to police, Silva was called to the apartment building after a resident reported that Newlon was yelling obscenities and scaring her. The resident, who was not identified, said Newlon’s anger may have been the result of her complaining to their landlord that he was “hoarding” items in the corner of the property’s carport.
As shown in the body-camera footage, Silva attempted to detain Newlon, first with verbal commands, which Newlon ignored. When Newlon placed his right hand in his pants pocket, Silva ordered him to “get your hands out of your pocket.”
In the video footage Newlon tells the officer that he is “suffering with a brain tumor right now.”
“My hormones are raging,” he says. “I could actually start out and break out and fight you, (expletive).”
Silva is shown trying to defuse Newlon’s anger by telling him to relax. But a minute later, he puts Newlon into a wrist-lock, and then brings him to the ground with his hand on Newlon’s neck. He repeatedly tells Newlon to get on his stomach, and threatens to use a Taser on him. Newlon is heard screaming in pain throughout the struggle, and yells that he is afraid he is having a heart attack.
Eventually, Silva put Newlon into a “carotid restraint,” commonly known as a sleeper hold, and Newlon passed out. Soon after, other officers arrived, ending the encounter. While police said Newlon was cited for battery on an officer and resisting arrest and placed on an involuntary mental health hold, no record of the citation could be found in the Santa Clara County court records system.
Newlon could not be reached for comment Friday at several phone numbers listed under his name. His landlord described him to police as a Navy veteran who suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder and a brain tumor, and the woman who called police said she only wanted him to get help.
Silva was the subject of public scrutiny after SB 1421 records released in July — first reported by the Bay Area News Group and KQED — revealed that he had been fired by San Jose State after a 2016 incident in which he brutally beat a man who was masturbating and watching porn in the campus library. The civil suit filed by the victim of the beating led to $950,000 settlement. But Silva got his job back on appeal and then left the university police department to work in Los Gatos for Chief Peter Decena, who was chief at San Jose State police during the 2016 encounter. At the time, Decena found that Silva had acted within department policy.
An outcry over the San Jose State case, led by a contingent of concerned Los Gatos residents, resulted in Silva leaving the Los Gatos department soon after the records were released.
This story was produced as part of the California Reporting Project, a collaboration of more than 40 newsrooms across the state to obtain and report on police misconduct and use-of-force records unsealed in 2019.
